1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

Lion-O's Surf2 Thread

Discussion in 'General Discussion' started by Turbo, Dec 30, 2013.

Welcome to Algae Scrubbing Join our community today
  1. lion-o

    lion-o New Member

    I'm about to just throw in the towel with this thing.

    I'm a very patient person but week after week I'm cleaning it out and just removing colored slime. And the algae in the display continues to bloom at pretty much the best it has been.

    I even added a kole yellow tang to try to get him munching on it, but he doesn't seem interested lol. He gobbles up his nori every day and I think he helps keep the glass clean (at least, that's what I think hes doing... really he looks like hes yelling at the glass and gumming it! :p).
     
  2. Turbo

    Turbo Does not really look like Johnny Carson Staff Member Site Owner Multiple Units! Customer

    If you can, try to recap the different stages and changes that you've seen. Something like:

    First week, lights X hrs/day, harvested after X days, color was X

    At the X week point, growth changed to X

    Changed light to X

    etc.

    I wanted to see if I could spot some kind of pattern with growth type/quantity vs light duration, days between cleaning, that type of thing. I haven't gone back to your other thread on the scrubber site, I figured I would just go right to you instead of assuming anything...try to fill in as much info as you can
     
  3. lion-o

    lion-o New Member

    That's going to take some digging for sure. I wish I could say I kept a journal of weekly progress but the thought never occurred to me. I thought a pic now and then would suffice :\

    I'll dig through my old post, and emails/pics and get back to you. I might be able to draw up a rough timeline.
     
  4. Turbo

    Turbo Does not really look like Johnny Carson Staff Member Site Owner Multiple Units! Customer

    yeah not looking for an exact timeline, just a general type of thing. If it's too much of a pain don't worry about it, I'm just trying to think of any way to pinpoint the issue. IMO, it's best to give advice based on the bigger picture and taking into consideration all that has been done/tried. Sometimes in order to figure this out, you need to look back at previous steps closer. But the bottom line is that something should have worked at some point along the way. I've had at least one customer that couldn't grow a smidge of algae on one of my L2s no matter what I recommended so there always is that possibility.
     
  5. Kerry

    Kerry Member Trusted Member Customer

    I have not read through your posts here or on the Scrubber site but if you have a lot of algae in the display you might need to cut the lights WAY back to 25-50% of the time and even remove some algae by hand. The lights in the display tank might be overpowering or out competing your surf2 device.
     
  6. lion-o

    lion-o New Member

    Ok, here goes - I think this is going to be as good as I can provide.

    Tank up and running - Dec 2009
    purchased 5/28/13
    shipped 6/13
    arrived & installed 6/26/13

    7/1 - fusion 700 air pump to max (for maximum bubblage)

    7/9 - so far no growth. 22 hours a day light. Rubbed in some "seed" algae from display

    7/26 - Thin green layer starting to spread in the scrubber

    <6 week vacation>

    9/30 - Entire scrubber is covered in green, but no tangible growth

    10/1 - Light scrubbing with a toothbrush in the sink
    At this point, started doing this cleaning once every 1-2 weeks

    10/18 - Green no longer, yellow/brownish color (like Cali kelp forest)

    11/2 - Same thing

    11/10 - Lights down to 18 hrs/day

    1/1 - Lights bumped back up to 22 hrs/day

    1/14 - Removed filter sock and phosban from the tank

    2/1 - Changed to two 6 hour photoperiods

    2/3 - Added the filter sock and phosban back into tank
     

    Attached Files:

  7. lion-o

    lion-o New Member

    Turbo, do you have a link to your scrubbers? I would be interested to check them out.
     
  8. Turbo

    Turbo Does not really look like Johnny Carson Staff Member Site Owner Multiple Units! Customer

  9. Kerry

    Kerry Member Trusted Member Customer

    I am glad you said that!!! I almost posted about a waterfall scrubber being much for efficient then the air bubble scrubber in my opinion. I have built many different type scrubbers in my day but I get the best results from my LED waterfall scrubber. I still maintain a horizontal on my QT/pod production tank due to necessity and I did have a air bubble scrubber lit on both sides that grew tons of 3D algae but still didnt cut it so it was changed to a waterfall type. Turbo's scrubbers are second to none in my opinion and if I was not able build one I would buy his.
     

Share This Page